You must remember this: in the journal Social Text published an essay by Alan Sokal called “Transgressing the boundaries: towards a. It’s time I introduced you to my hero: Alan Sokal. He wrote and submitted a spoof article, Transgressing the Boundaries: Towards a. Biographical Information: The author is a Professor of Physics at New York University. He has lectured widely in Europe and Latin America, including at the.

Author: Faejas Zugore
Country: Saint Kitts and Nevis
Language: English (Spanish)
Genre: Technology
Published (Last): 26 October 2004
Pages: 35
PDF File Size: 17.30 Mb
ePub File Size: 8.28 Mb
ISBN: 743-4-34353-309-1
Downloads: 82551
Price: Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]
Uploader: Kagakree

Retrieved 1 March Hilgartner argued that the intellectual impact of the successful Sokal hoax cannot be attributed to its quality as a “demonstration” but rather to journalistic hyperbole and the anti-intellectual trnsgressing of some American journalists.

This page was last edited on 4 Decemberat Quantum Gravity in Philosophy of Physical Science categorize this paper.

Transgressing the Boundaries: Towards a Transformative Hermeneutics of Quantum Gravity

Writing after the article was published and the hoax revealed, he stated:. In the French, his citation from the original hoax article is said to be an “isolated” instance of abuse, [19] whereas the English text adds a parenthetical remark that Boundares work contained “no systematic misuse or indeed attention to science.

The Sleep of Reason. Just as liberal feminists are frequently content with a minimal agenda of legal and social equality for women and ” pro-choice “, so liberal and even some socialist mathematicians are often content to work within the hegemonic Zermelo—Fraenkel framework which, reflecting its nineteenth-century liberal origins, already incorporates the axiom of equality supplemented only by the axiom of choice. Paul Boghossian – – Times Literary Supplement. By flattering the editors’ ideological preconceptions, he hoped his meaningless waffle might just get published.


They attacked him for dishonesty and slkal post-modernist commentators suggested he needed psychiatric treatment. Jerold Touger – unknown.

Loading comments… Trouble loading? They apparently felt no need to analyze the quality of the evidence, the cogency of the arguments, or even the relevance of the arguments to the purported conclusion. We’ve been focusing on the negative for wokal long: My goal isn’t to defend science from the barbarian hordes of lit crit we’ll survive just fine, thank youbut to defend the Left from a trendy segment transgreessing itself.

Johns Hopkins University Press, But sloppy sociology, like sloppy science, is useless, or even counterproductive. It wouldn’t, of course, have been if the sociologists I use the term loosely hadn’t played along by crying foul, or, more reasonably, “category error”; on the whole they didn’t see the joke, or, if they saw it, didn’t like it. Alan Sokal – manuscript. The Sokal Affair scandal extended from academia to the public press.

Talk about bad science We’ve been focusing on the negative for too long: Instead, they speculated Tbe admission “represented a change of heart, or a folding alam his intellectual resolve”. Towards a Rransgressing Hermeneutics of Quantum Gravity” was the only article submitted by a natural scientist.

In the May issue of Lingua Francain the article “A Physicist Experiments With Cultural Studies”, Sokal revealed that “Transgressing the Boundaries” was a hoax and concluded that Social Text “felt comfortable publishing an article on quantum physics without bothering to consult anyone knowledgeable in the subject” because of its ideological proclivities and editorial bias.

Sokal found further humor in the idea that the article’s absurdity was hard to spot:. Bboundaries political pragmatist, Sokal doubted they had much to offer. The anthropologist Bruno Latourcriticized in Fashionable Nonsense transgresxing, described the scandal as a ” tempest in a tea cup “. Show 25 25 50 All.


Social Text’ s response revealed that none of the editors had suspected Sokal’s piece was a parody. It proposed that quantum gravity is a social and linguistic construct.

Sokal affair – Wikipedia

University of Nebraska Press, He advised readers to slowly and skeptically examine the arguments proposed by each party, bearing in mind that “the obvious is sometimes the enemy of the true”. Sarah Glazer – – Nursing Philosophy 2 3: History of Western Philosophy. Topics Research Bad science.

Towards biundaries Transformative Hermeneutics of Quantum Gravity”.

At Whom Are We Laughing? Towards a Transformative Hermeneutics of Quantum Gravity” proposed that quantum gravity has progressive political implications, and that the ” morphogenetic field ” could be a cutting-edge theory of quantum gravity a morphogenetic field is a concept adapted by Rupert Sheldrake in a way that Sokal characterized in the affair’s aftermath as “a bizarre New Age idea”.

When he returned to America, the liberal left agenda seemed to have been hijacked by hip intellectuals and postmodernist literary theorists teaching that transgressinng is a socially constructed text, about which you can say anything, as long as you say it murkily. The results of my little experiment demonstrate, at the very least, that some fashionable sectors of the American academic Left have been getting intellectually lazy.