A Rulebook for Arguments has ratings and reviews. Kirstine said: If you want to be good at arguing, this book is for you. I read it all in one. Short Arguments: Some General Rules Arguments begin by marshaling reasons and organizing them in a clear and fair way. Chapter I offers general rules for. A Rulebook for Arguments by Anthony Weston – book review By Eko Rustamaji ( ) Description A Rulebook for Arguments was written by Anthony.

Author: Faegrel Shakashakar
Country: Anguilla
Language: English (Spanish)
Genre: Medical
Published (Last): 20 January 2010
Pages: 447
PDF File Size: 14.43 Mb
ePub File Size: 6.68 Mb
ISBN: 660-2-34635-838-6
Downloads: 92340
Price: Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]
Uploader: Arashitilar

Nevertheless, the bibliography or all references used by the writer are not provided in the last page of the book. It is the main points of the essay.

A Rulebook for Arguments

There is also addendums on oral arguments, fallacies, definition, and a note on the place anthoony argument in the studies of logic and rhetoric. Feedback is a “reality check” all the way around –welcome it.

This handbook is very short and basic. The author developed rules of thumb in argumentation and demonstrated the practicality in fro examples mostly from Betrand Russell’s essays and Sherlock Holmes’ deductions. Published January 1st by Hackett Publishing Company first published The first chapter is Composing a Short Argument.

It’s concise and easy to read. The rules and tips provided in the book are only the ways to developing and delivering arguments. Weston also wseton examples of good and bad arguments so that the important aspects and even the most common fallacies are cove I bought this book because I wanted to find a short and simple instructions for planning and writing solid arguments mainly for my thesis.

It’s small, argjments to weshon, easy to read, and is incredibly useful as a resource to help one hone his or her skills in analyzing the logic of I took some notes. The ideas and arguments provided in Rulebook for Arguments are of the important points in learning how to develop good arguments because making and developing a good argument must follow some tips and rules.


First part of the book is about short arguments. The author claims that this book is designed to fulfill a need for a “rulebook” vs.

The fourth edition, even more elegantly organized argumwnts concise than before, adds new material on oral presentations and Web sources that everyone needs. The Writer uses persuasive rulbook logical language also highly academic in the book. Therefore, argument is of extreme importance to preachers.

Logic and Rhetoric in England, Isn’t it easier to just tell someone to “Be concrete and concise” rather than to refer them to Rule 4 in their rulebook? It is rather than multiplying examples to support generalization, argue from one specific case or example to another example, reasoning that because the two examples are alike in many ways, they are also alike in one further antbony way.

Sep 01, Madeleine Lesieutre rated it really liked it Shelves: Premises you thought were secure may turn out to need defending, while other premises may turn out to be more secure than they seemed. Click here to sign up.

The author gives only what is needed to know and no more. Mostly vocabs or words used in this book is highly academic words but logic, which can be understood easily.

A Rulebook for Arguments by Anthony Weston

A Rulebook for Arguments invites comparison to Strunk and White’s Elements of Style ; the author recommends keeping his own title next to the latter on the shelf. Find it on Scholar. See 1 question about A Rulebook for Arguments…. A few interesting points here and there, but nothing that the argments person couldn’t arrive at with a few seconds’ thinking.


Anthony Weston, A Rulebook for Arguments – PhilPapers

This 85pg book accomplished much of its aim: Remember me on this computer. Favorite section is the one on fallacies. It is concise, easy to read and full of concrete examples to apply and support the countless tips and advices in the book. Regularity-based argumentation which is used in support of a descriptive statement about the present, the past or the future, Rule-based argumentation used in support of normative statement about the value, and Pragmatic argumentation which is leading to a wfston about the desirability of a given action.

It is not a mistake to have strong views. It can be used as a reference for the students who want to improve their argumentation skill weeston this book contains the tips in composing short arguments until composing an argumentative essay. westkn

Readers familiar with the previous edition will find a text that retains all the features that make Rulebook ideally suited for use as a supplementary course book — including its modest price and compact size. It really undermines the purpose of the book.

An excellent reference piece for all college students and very inexpensive. Flows as nicely as possible.

The author does also give some sources for larger works if the reader is interested.